Warm late-autumn light falls across two tidy single-story ranch homes and landscaped back gardens in a quiet Silverton neighborhood.

Holiday City at Silverton's Two Associations and What Each One Costs a Buyer

On Election Day, November 3, Holiday City Association Phase 1 residents voted at the Phase 2 clubhouse at 1846 Yorktowne Boulevard. Their own polling place had moved because nobody could promise that repairs at their clubhouse would be finished in time. The community runs along one boulevard and has two clubhouses, two boards, two dues bills and two sets of fees.

If you are shopping here as a downsizer, or helping a parent buy, that split shapes your costs more than most of what a listing shows. In 2026 the two associations collect their money in different ways. Phase 1 has committed its owners to a dues schedule that rises and is fixed through 2030. Phase 2 keeps its yearly dues low and collects a larger amount when a home is sold. Two nearly identical ranches a few streets apart can therefore cost different amounts to buy into and to own.

Two boards on one boulevard

Ocean County's list of adult communities counts 602 units in Phase 1 and 935 in Phase 2. Toms River Township's Community Facilities Element gives 936 for Phase 2, so think of both figures as approximate. Phase 1 is the Holiday City Association, based at Clubhouse #1, 2170 Yorktowne Boulevard, and managed by Towne & Country Management. Phase 2 is the Holiday City Organization, based at 1846 Yorktowne Boulevard.

The two associations get mixed up often enough that Phase 2's bookkeeper posted a list of wrong ways to fill out a check on the Holiday City Organization's Services & Notices page. The list ends with "Holiday City Association (that is Phase I not us)." The same notice tells people to send mail to 1846 Yorktowne, "NOT 2170 Yorketowne Blvd. That is Phase I." If owners who already live here mix up their checks, a buyer looking at two listings with the same community name can easily mix up which rules and fees apply. The phase a house belongs to tells you which bill comes with it.

Phase 1's bill is set through 2030

The Holiday City Association's November 2026 bulletin lays out the dues schedule. Until this year, a Phase 1 owner's dues were the $240 operating portion. After the association completed its required capital reserve studies, it adopted a funding plan that added a $190 capital reserve contribution per unit, effective May 1, 2026. That brought 2026 annual dues to $430, payable quarterly. Starting January 1, 2027, the reserve contribution rises to $240, and annual dues will be $480 for each year from 2027 through 2030.

For a buyer, the useful part is how predictable this is. Someone who buys in Phase 1 this winter can see their association dues for the next four years in a published table, with the operating share held at $240 each year.

The clubhouse is the Phase 1 project most likely to shape a buyer's first year. The November bulletin says repairs at Clubhouse #1 had been expected to be well underway by now. The township asked for some changes to the plans, the engineers resubmitted them, and the permits are approved, so the association is "cleared to begin repairs." The bulletin gives no date for when the work will start or finish. A buyer who is counting on clubhouse events should ask the Phase 1 office where the project stands.

Phase 2 keeps dues at $25 a month and collects when homes sell

Phase 2 charges much less each year. The Holiday City Organization bills $75 a quarter, due in January, April, July and October, with a $10 late fee. That comes to $300 for the year. The March 2026 newsletter explains how that number was set. At the April 2025 meeting, a large majority of members voted to raise annual dues to $25 a month. At the same meeting, the board used a resolution to raise three other fees. The buy-in fee for a new homeowner went from $1,500 to $2,000. The hall rental fee went from $125 to $250. The home rental fee went from $100 to $500. The resolution was recorded with the Ocean County Clerk, and a membership vote to ratify those fee increases was scheduled for March 9, 2026.

The Holiday City Organization's website now lists a "$2,000 initial fee per new homeowner each time a home is sold," and a $500 fee for each tenant change.

In the November 2026 newsletter, the Phase 2 president credits the volunteers who run Friday night Bingo with helping keep maintenance fees at $25 a month. The same report says the association spends more than $15,000 a year to keep its lakes healthy. The website describes Phase 2 as having a large clubhouse, a swimming pool, two large lakes and 45 acres of common grounds. In 2026 the pool opened on Saturday, May 23, and closed on September 22.

The same four years, added up two ways

Take a buyer who closes this winter and owns from 2027 through 2030.

In Phase 1, the dues schedule totals $1,920 over those four years, at $480 a year. In Phase 2, four years at today's $300 a year comes to $1,200. Add the $2,000 new-owner fee and the total is $3,200. The Phase 2 total assumes the $25 monthly fee stays the same for four years, and no one has published a schedule that says it will. A buyer in either phase should ask the association office for its complete list of current charges before comparing totals.

The comparison changes as the years go on. Phase 2's dues are $180 a year lower than Phase 1's 2027 rate, so the longer someone stays, the more of the $2,000 entry fee those savings cover. A buyer planning to stay a few years and one planning to stay twenty are making different calculations.

What the dues leave to each owner

Both phases charge dues that are low next to the monthly fees many buyers expect from an adult community. One reason is that owners take care of much of their own property. Phase 2's snow notice reminds owners to move cars off the street before the plows come. It also asks residents who travel in winter to arrange for someone to clear their driveway and sidewalk. The same page asks residents who spend winters in Florida or elsewhere to leave a phone number where they can be reached. After a big snowstorm, the association could not contact owners whose Florida rooms were damaged.

The associations spend their money on what everyone shares: the clubhouses, the lakes and the common grounds. In its November newsletter, Phase 2 says it will mulch and clean the common grounds once the leaves are down, and it asks owners and their landscapers not to blow leaves into the storm drains, which empty into the lakes. Phase 1's bulletin explains how residents can request lake-access and fishing permits.

A buyer coming from a community where the HOA covers lawns and snow should plan for those services separately here, in either phase. Those costs depend on the yard and the contractor, and they belong in the same budget as the dues.

Before you write an offer here

Confirm the phase before you compare houses. The Holiday City Organization office for Phase 2 is at 732-255-2221. Phase 1 handles its business through Towne & Country Management at 732-212-8200. Once you know the phase, ask that office for its current dues schedule and its full list of fees. Then use those figures when you compare two listings. In Phase 1, ask where the clubhouse repairs stand. In Phase 2, ask whether any dues changes are coming for 2027.

The figures here come from the associations' own 2026 newsletters and website and are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the costs for a specific home with the association and the right professional.

If you are weighing a house in Holiday City at Silverton, or helping a parent sell one, The Shore Standard can help you confirm which association a home belongs to and set its dues and fees side by side with the rest of what we know about Silverton. If you are selling, start with a free home valuation, and see our seller resources for the steps that follow.

Your Shore Living Experts

The Shore Standard is a real estate team built on a simple idea: treat every client the way we’d want to be treated. No gimmicks, no high-pressure tactics — just honest guidance from people who genuinely know and love the Jersey Shore.

Follow Us on Instagram